In short: the best way to test a developer is a paid trial of 3–5 days on a real, small task from your backlog. Give them a clear brief and access to your tools, check in once a day, and judge four things: code quality, communication, speed and how they handle feedback. One week of real work tells you more than three rounds of interviews.
Interviews and coding puzzles show whether someone can talk about code. A trial shows whether they can work with your codebase, your tools and your team, which is what you are actually paying for.
Why a trial beats interviews alone
- You see real code in your real project, not a whiteboard answer
- You learn how they ask questions and report progress, which matters even more with remote developers
- You find out how much of your team's time they need: a good developer needs about 1–2 hours a day of review and answers in the first week, not 5
- The developer learns whether they like the work, so fewer people leave after a month
How to choose a good trial task
A good trial task is:
- Real: something from your backlog that you actually need, not a made-up exercise
- Small: doable in 2–4 days by a competent developer, leaving time for questions and review
- Self-contained: it doesn't need deep knowledge of your whole system
- Representative: it uses the same technology and kind of work as the role
Good examples: a new page or feature with an API call, a reported bug plus a test that proves it is fixed, an integration with a payment or email service, or improving the speed of a slow page.
A 1-week developer trial plan
| Day | What happens | What you are checking |
|---|---|---|
| Day 1 | 30-minute kickoff call, access to the repository and task board, brief explained | Do they ask good questions? Can they set up the project on their own? |
| Day 2 | Work starts; short written update at the end of the day | Clear progress updates, early flagging of blockers |
| Day 3 | First pull request or demo of work in progress | Code structure, naming, small focused commits |
| Day 4 | Your team reviews the code and gives feedback | How they respond to feedback and how quickly they act on it |
| Day 5 | Final demo and short call | Is it finished, tested and documented? Would you merge it? |
How do you score a developer trial?
Score each area from 1 to 5 and write one sentence of evidence for each score. Decide in advance that anything below 3 in communication or code quality is a no.
- Code quality: readable, consistent with your style, tested, no unnecessary complexity
- Communication: daily updates without chasing, clear questions, honest about problems
- Speed: reasonable progress for the task size; not rushed and not stuck for days in silence
- Feedback: accepts review comments, fixes them properly, doesn't argue every point
- Independence: how much of your team's time they needed
Warning signs during a trial
- Silence for a whole day, then a large drop of code at once
- Code copied from elsewhere that they can't explain
- Changes to files that had nothing to do with the task
- "Done" without tests, or without checking it works on mobile
- A different person on the call from the one who was interviewed
Should a developer trial be paid?
Yes. Unpaid "tests" of several days put off the best developers, who have other options. Pay a fair day rate or, when working with a development company, agree the trial terms in advance. Many companies offer a short trial so you can judge the developer before committing to a monthly plan.
What to protect before the trial starts
- Sign a short NDA and an agreement that the trial work belongs to you
- Give access to a single repository or a copy, not your whole system
- Use test data, never real customer data
- Remove access as soon as the trial ends if you don't continue
Try a Rachyet developer on a real task
When you hire developers with Rachyet, you interview the developer yourself, and we can start with a short trial task from your backlog so you see real work before you commit to a monthly plan. Compare the options in what it costs to hire a developer, or tell us about the role and we will suggest a trial task with you.